Monthly Archives: December 2014

Purview and Purpose of Peer Review

All research papers have to go through a rigorous process of review before getting published. Since all publications resort to independent peer review, having your paper reviewed beforehand by experienced peer review experts will make your journey to publication hassle free by improving the quality of your paper.

What is peer review?

Peer review means a thorough assessment of a research paper by experts from the concerned field. These experts may be academicians or professionals, with in depth knowledge about the issue discussed in the paper. To be effective, peer review must be unbiased. Hence, most universities and publication houses follow the double blinded refereeing process for peer review, where the identity of the author is not revealed to the reviewer.

Purpose of Peer Review

Through a peer review, the following points are verified:

• Whether the paper is in line with the accepted research standards in terms of language used
• The format and presentation are up to the mark
• Data and statements presented in the paper are valid and the analysis is accurate
• There is no plagiarism in content, and ideas stated by the author are original
• The issue discussed is relevant and the results are meaningful, providing solutions that are practically applicable

In case some flaw is revealed during the review, the same is pointed out and corrections are suggested. Editors use the peer reviewer’s report to judge the value of a research paper that is submitted for publication.

Before you send your paper to a peer reviewer, enquire thoroughly about her credentials; or you can choose to take help from a trusted service provider that has well known peer reviewers on board. Pay attention to the advice offered by the experts and edit appropriately to make your paper flawless.